29: Rings of Power S3 E3 “The Secret Fire” & E4 “Gundabad”

Greetings to all the free peoples of Middle Earth,

Penny and Veronica travel to Rhun, Khazad Dum and the Western shores of Numenor, visit Sauron in Barad Dur and road trip to Gundabad on the one show to rule them all…

To keep pace with the streaming schedule, each episode of ‘Cast of the Rings will cover two episodes this season. As always, we love to hear from our listeners. You can send us your questions, notes and observations on Facebook or emails or voice notes to talk@podcastica.com. Please include which episode or episodes your message is about.

Namárië

Links:

THE RINGS OF POWER Showrunners Explain Why Season 3 Is Getting an Unusual Release Schedule — GeekTyrant

The Rings of Power Showrunner Reveals The Big Risk Season 3 Is Taking With Some Characters, And It Could Definitely Backfire - ComicBook.com

—-------------------

You can find our contact info and all our other shows at: www.podcastica.com.

For those wanting to explore further, you can find an encyclopedia of everything from Tolkien’s works here: glyphweb.com.

To explore the world of Middle Earth portrayed in the books and on screen, go to: lotr.fandom.com

For even more Tolkien goodness, try this fan wiki Tolkien Gateway

Music: Now We Ride by Alexander Nakarada (www.serpentsoundstudios.com)

Licensed under Creative Commons BY Attribution 4.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

[00:00:00] Oh no, no, no, no What is this? Or painted? Is that some sort of poem? Just a fastening of words is all about we might we found. What's a poem? You care to recite the rest? Are you embarrassed? No, just ain't finished yet, and it ain't fit for fancy ears.

[00:00:38] My ears are not too fancy. Are your ears too fancy, Commander? My dog's ears are too fancy.

[00:00:45] He fell among the rotted leaves, Below a night sky painted black, A fellow lost that no one grieves. This warg dung, Worse than a troll dung.

[00:01:12] It's not that bad. A fur and oak? Greetings, Uruk poets, eagle princes, and newly made ring servants. Welcome to our podcast. I'm Penny.

[00:01:42] And I'm Veronica. And this is The Cast of the Rings, Episode 29. This episode, we're going to cover The Rings of Power Season 3, Episode 3, The Secret Fire, and Episode 4, Gundabad. So, overall thoughts? What did you think of these two episodes?

[00:02:03] I'm a little gutted. They really hurt me pretty bad. I am really glad that I got to watch the first two episodes and sort of take a break and thoroughly enjoy those before we moved into these.

[00:02:24] And I'm really glad that I got to watch the first two episodes. And after I've watched, like, what are the things that really stood out? And then when I watch again, I take notes as I go.

[00:02:52] And the only thing I wrote down after the first watch through was a very long expletive and then, no, not R.O.N.D.E.R. Like, I just, that's all I had in me after it. I still feel like such a, I mean, for me, like, more than just Aaron Deer, like, I can't, I'm tearing up a little bit just talking about it.

[00:03:18] I don't know, but Theo's story and how we got here, I don't know. I, it's compounded that loss and I just feel so sad. It is sad. It's very sad. Yeah. Um, let's, let's just start there in our main points and talk about it. Yeah.

[00:03:38] Um, Theo, in that final scene, he looked, the look on his face was pained. Yeah. Like, and he, when he warned Aaron Deer to walk away, he was like, if he tells him to kill you, I'm gonna do it. And he never used the words like compelled, forced, like, I have to because of the ring, no choice. He just said, I will do it.

[00:04:08] And it made me think that, that Aaron Deer thought he really could like talk him out. Like, no, come with us. Like, you don't have to, to do this. And I don't think that that was ever going to work. I don't think so either, but I think I did not realize how like much my heart cared about Theo as a character.

[00:04:34] And I think even though I knew what you were said is true, and I knew where this was going all along. Um, and especially in those moments, like I knew there was no turning back. There was still such a big part of me that was just hoping that he was going to turn back, even though I knew it was irrational.

[00:05:01] And I think for Aaron Deer, he probably knew that too, but irrationally hoped. And I don't think there was another choice for him because if he left, he was leaving with an even heavier burden of responsibility than he already felt sort of for his role and where Theo was.

[00:05:24] And I think if he ran away, I think it would have killed him anyways to leave Theo in that state. I mean, I think he, he was already carrying that burden of feeling like he'd left Theo. And so then to see where leaving Theo sort of led, I don't know. I don't know if he could have walked away. Yeah, I don't either. I wanted him to, when I watched it the second time, I was like, just go, just go. You could just go.

[00:05:55] But he, you know, he didn't go. I had a hard time watching it through the second time. Like I, I stopped this, that episode about halfway through and like walked away and started doing other stuff. I was like, I can't, I don't, I don't want to watch that again. It was awful for both of them. It was so sad. And that final shot when, when, when Sauron is like, leave him. And then they're there, you know, they walk out and, and Theo picks up his helmet.

[00:06:22] And he, he sadly walks like towards the screen away from Arondir's body. And it just this like windswept, like bitter gray, cold scene. And the look on his face is like, this is my life now, like despair, but like settled. Like this. Yeah. Resigned to it. Yeah. And, and then Arondir's like beautiful light blue eyes, like just staring.

[00:06:51] But the snowflakes like landing on his cheeks. Yeah. It was beautiful and terrible. Yeah. I felt like it gave Arondir like an ending fit for the amazing character he'd been. And I mean, he did some really heroic things, some beautiful fighting, you know, came full circle on his sort of opinions and willingness to partner with an orc.

[00:07:20] Um, Marnuk. And so like, those are all aligned with the good, like strong character that he's been. And then to die still not like physically fighting, but fighting for someone that he loved and cared about.

[00:07:39] I think it was at least like a really beautiful, consistent way for that character to go out and lovely that we got those final shots you described sort of lingering. Yeah. Um, so I guess. Yeah. Silver lining of just like honor to a good character. If I have to be really, really sad that he's gone though. Yeah.

[00:08:04] I mean, we've lost other characters that we cared about, but this one is probably the hardest so far. I was really in love with Caleb Rimbor last season and losing him was hard, but I knew the whole time that it was coming. But I think that was interesting with Aaron Deer because he's a show only character. For all we know, he was going to go on to become like Legolas's grandfather. Like it, there was nothing that dictated that, that the character was definitely not going to make it out of the show.

[00:08:32] So, so that was rough, really rough and not, I wasn't ready for it. Um, I didn't expect it either. But beautifully well done. Yeah. Yeah. Like I expected, you know, if the girl was going down this route that the interesting story point was eventually going to be for them to have these encounters, but I did not expect it to end with Aaron Deer's death this quickly.

[00:08:59] They've just been ripping the bandaid off of certain things this season. It feels like. Yeah, they, I think it's moving kind of quickly. Yeah. Um, it, it seems, it feels very much like plot point, plot point, plot point. And I don't know that that's necessarily a bad thing.

[00:09:16] I know that some audience members have sort of complained in the past that the show was slow, but the slow parts are usually my favorite parts when you get a lot of like marinating and character development and, and more subtle storytelling. Right now we seem to be in the middle of the rising action. And so a quicker pace to the show seems reasonable for that, but I'm a little bit like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Can we just take a second?

[00:09:44] Like, I thought the road trip was going to last a little longer. And I, I thought that the, the prison break was maybe going to be its whole own episode. I was sort of ready for that to be more of like a heist movie, like a mini heist movie, but it was, it was like, like 25% of the episode. It just wasn't that much of it. Right? It was still good, but it just wasn't as much as I expected. I, I was ready for it to be slower this season, but, um, I'm getting with the program.

[00:10:15] Uh, Ismael Cruz Cordoba. I, I was like, oh no, we're going to lose him from the show. And so I was like, what else is he doing? And he recently was, um, in a smallish part in the movie Verity, which I saw was very entertaining movie. Um, but it's not a very big role, but he has something that he's working on right now on his IMDB page called Puerto Rico P O R T O Rico. And it's based on a true story about this historic figure. And the cast is bonkers.

[00:10:45] It's him, Viggo Mortensen, Bad Bunny, Edward Norton, and like a whole bunch of other people. Yeah. Bonkers cast. So I'm very excited to see that movie when it comes out. Yeah. That sounds awesome. I was like, I wonder if he and Viggo Mortensen had some like, like Lord of the Rings bonding. Yeah. If they like had a moment. I'm sure because everything I've heard about Viggo Mortensen is that he's like still kind of a little bit Aragorn. Yeah.

[00:11:12] Uh, the new guy who's playing Aragorn in the, in the hunt for Gollum movies, Jamie Dornan. Yeah. I saw an interview with him where he was like, oh, I'm so lucky because Viggo just agreed to meet with me and help me work on my character. And I was like, he really is Aragorn. Yeah. He's amazing. Such a good, he's always like rescuing horses and stuff. I love this man. Oh. It's lovely.

[00:11:37] So other than the, the sort of gloom retrospectively put over these episodes because of our loss of our beloved Aragorn dear. Um, what other things stuck out to you about these two episodes? What do you want to talk about? Oh, I want to talk about Tom Bombadil because I've been singing that song for the last several days over and over driving everyone in my house crazy.

[00:12:02] Um, and I hope that saying goodbye to Tom in these episodes wasn't really saying goodbye to Tom. Um, I looked it up and the little song. Well, first I thought maybe the words to the song he was singing to Gandalf meant something that maybe that was the hint he was giving to Gandalf.

[00:12:27] I think the hint was just, well, one, he was just trying to get him to like, I think go chase that rabbit. But I think, I think, and I'm curious if this is your interpretation too, that he's basically telling Gandalf, if you sing this song at some point, if you need help from me, I'll come. Um, and that's something that we know of from the fellowship of the ring.

[00:12:53] When Tom Bombadil is first mentioned that he does give a song to Frodo and company. It's a different song. It's Oh, Tom Bombadil, Tom Bombadillo. It's a different little rhyme. Mm hmm. And they end up using it when they're in with the Barrow Whites. Right. And they sing that song and he comes and rescues them. And what he actually sings to them after he rescues them is the song that he sings to Gandalf in this episode. Right.

[00:13:22] Which I thought was pretty cool, like the reference over to that. I know a lot of book fans were very disappointed that Tom Bombadil and that whole pair of stories like visiting with him and him rescuing them from the Barrow Downs didn't make it into the movies. And there's been chatter for the last 20 some odd years about it and people being like, we were cheated of Tom Bombadil.

[00:13:46] And, and so putting him in the show has, I think, been like a little bit of a bomb to that. Yeah, that audience. And I think they've been using little bits and pieces of the actual dialogue and songs from fellowship for Tom to sort of make up for it in a way sort of in a very, like, indirect way.

[00:14:10] Yeah, I got this. I think that his songs in general, all of them are kind of about like, figure it out and trust nature and be a good person. Like there's, they're not complicated songs. They're about nature and stuff. And I think Tom's whole thing, like we saw it when they were undercover and when he was like, fine, I'll give you some, some guidance. Like, it's always been sort of like riddly and indirect, but basically it's about like, figure your own self out.

[00:14:38] And it's not always what you think it is, like be open to something being different than what it is. And that's, that's what Gandalf keeps having to learn over and over again. Like he thought that he was, you know, straying from the path when he went to save his friends last season, but that was actually exactly his path. Yeah. I thought the secret fire was kind of goofy. Yeah. I.

[00:15:09] It's very strange. And I appreciated. And when sent us that article sort of explaining more about the secret fire and. As someone who grew up in a very Christian. Setting. They liken the secret fire to essentially like the Holy spirit. Which is the spiritual embodiment, which I don't know if embodiment is the right word to use.

[00:15:37] Cause to me that inherently suggests like a physical form, but it's. Right. Like the in world spiritual representation of God or in this setting. Eru, I guess. Right. Is like the creator. And so. Yeah. I like to think of it as being. Equivalent to the thing in our universe, in our real world universe. That creates life. Whether that is. An anthropomorphic being. Known as God.

[00:16:06] Or if it's just like a force in the universe, like gravity. Mm-hmm. I think of that creative force that creates life as. As similar to this secret fire. Which is why having it speak English. To me was super weird. Like it didn't even speak Quenya. It. It spoke English. English to Gamble. Yeah, I'm surprised they didn't subtitle it and have it be another language. Yeah. That just struck me as corny. It also had like Moses vibes. Like.

[00:16:36] The burning bush in the desert. I was like, all right. That's a little on the nose. It made me think a lot about though about. I read the article too that Anwen sent us about. What the secret fire is. And it. What interested me the most was that. That. No being. Could be created. By anyone like. Like. Morgoth or Melkor could not make beings because they could not command the secret fire.

[00:17:03] And therefore he couldn't give a being like autonomous life. Yeah. And. I was thinking about how. Sauron says that like the fell beast. The like flying dragon wormy thing that. That he had. Used to be an eagle. And was corrupted by Morgoth. And how. In this universe. The story is that orcs. Came from elves. That were corrupted by. Sauron and Morgoth.

[00:17:32] And how this is just like more evidence. Of that like the secret fire. Couldn't be wielded by them. Yeah. But. And also how Gandalf was like. I need to learn how to use it. And. And Tom Bombadil's like. You have to learn how to serve it. Because like only. Basically only the highest of the Valar can. Use it. The secret fire was also kind of snotty with him. What did it say to him? It said. Like you don't know me.

[00:18:01] Which was hilarious. Yeah. Yeah. I am that which burns within all things. Yet still remains seen. I built the heavens and stars. And all of Middle Earth is cradled within my flame. Even using the word I is really funny. Like. Yeah. I feel like. I just. It. Seems like there could have been a different way. To have this community. Like this mission. And. They.

[00:18:31] Communicated to Gandalf. Without introducing this sort of weird. Exposition. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It did sort of jump us past a bunch of stuff. That we were saying last time. That we didn't want to waste time figuring out. Fair. Like who is this other wizard? Like just tell us already. So they did. They just told us already. Yeah. Like we even got a name. Polander. And. And now Gandalf knows exactly what his mission is. It's to save. Polander. Polander. Polander. Polander.

[00:19:01] Yeah. I had it as Orlando in my notes. But I knew that was wrong. It's Pallando. Pallando. I'm glad we can stop calling him the dark wizard. Because that was. Right. And we also saw. You know. They confirmed. A couple of different ways this episode. But explicitly with the secret fire. That Pallando had killed his partner. That came with him. And they showed two wizards. All in blue. Standing on a ledge.

[00:19:29] And then runes sort of being destroyed. In front of them. And so I think. From that. We can conclude that. He is definitely. At least at some point. Was a blue wizard. Yeah. Right. I think that's clear. Yeah. And that he's. He. In the beginning. In the very opening scene. Or the first scene where we see him. He's like. Trying to make a plant bloom. Yeah. And it fails. And he gets all like morose about it. And he won't explain it to his person. But it.

[00:19:58] It's because he feels responsible for rune being a sort of lifeless desert. Right. It's his fault. It's interesting. He also. The blue wizard had such a. He had such a big episode. Episode three. Because. He had this whole power struggle with Kamul. Right. And it was so funny to me. Kamul shows up. All in a new outfit. Wearing the ring. And. Dark wizard is like. All right. Give me my ring. And he's like. No.

[00:20:28] I'm not going to give you my ring. And he's like. No. But it's mine. And he's like. No. It's. It's not. It's mine though. And he's like. Oh. Good news everyone. Sauron. Accepted. Right. Our alliance. It's all good. Everything's good. And it's like. What? Did. Were you in the room? Did you hear what just happened? And Kamul was having none of it. He was like. My army. Will meet up with these people. And we're going to go. Joints out. It. And then. They had the shot. Of the dark wizard. Like sitting all like. Lonely and dejected. And slumped over.

[00:20:58] I was like. Oh. A lot happened in two minutes. Right. That guy's whole life fell apart. I mean. I guess. You can't blame a guy. For trying. But it was such. Like a pathetic attempt. When he tried to make that announcement. Like. Everyone was just standing. In the room sir. And like saw. And heard what happened. Yeah. I don't know. And they all also saw. That this guy's face is pretty now. Right. So like. They're like. Whoa. Look at all that power. He. You know. Look at him. He's got the ring.

[00:21:27] He's got this cool new outfit. And he's all confident. And he's pretty. Like. They're ready to follow him. And then. I was thinking about how. The dark wizard had prepped all of them. To be like. We're going to follow Sauron. And they're all like. We're with you man. And then this new guy's like. I'm the servant of Sauron. And they're like. All right. That's what we signed up for. Like. He didn't train them to be loyal to him. He trained them to be loyal to whoever was. Like sort of wins. Yeah. So he lost all of his followers.

[00:21:57] It's kind of his own fault. Yeah. I mean. I'm not sad for him. No. Because he's a horrible person. But. I'm interested to see. You know. What becomes of Gandalf's attempt to save him. And. How they might change our feelings about him. As the story progresses. Because. I feel like they've got me rollercoastering all over the place. With some of my emotions around these characters. Yeah.

[00:22:27] I wonder if they'll give him. A bad guy to good guy. Makeover. I kind of hope not. Because I really enjoy his gigantic bushy eyebrows. But they do tend to make him look kind of evil. Yeah. They have a lot of sort of. I mean. I feel like Farizan is sort of the same way. Of like. You know. The equivalent of like a mustache twirling villain. But it's like eyebrow twirling.

[00:22:57] Right? Eyebrow twirling villain. That's pretty good. It's enjoyable. I. I love the. The sort of visual cues. But I. One of the things I've always liked about Tolkien. Is that. Very early on in Fellowship of the Ring. They have this conversation about. What's evil might appear fair. And feel bad. And what's bad. Might look good. Wait. I said the same thing twice. What. And what's good. Might not look good on the surface.

[00:23:27] Because they're talking about how Aragorn. Is sort of living as Strider. And he's like. He just looks like a dirty guy from the woods. A hot. Dirty guy from the woods. And. And. The hobbits are talking about how like. You know. But. Good may not always look good. And bad may not always look bad. And. And I've always appreciated that. Thought. And that lesson about the world. Because it is true. About humans and. And things. And. I'm just sort of hoping. I don't know if I want.

[00:23:57] Polando to get. A makeover or not. I. I kind of want him to keep his. His eyebrows. But like. Maybe wear different colors. Or something. Yeah. Because. If he can. I trust that actor. Karen Hines. To be able to pull off. Seeming. Different. But looking the same. Yeah. He's a talented guy. He's played. That actor has played. Julius Caesar. And then. In Rome.

[00:24:26] And Mance Rayder. In Game of Thrones. Oh my gosh. Yeah. He disappears into this role. Because of all the. Like air. I did not realize. He was Mance Rayder. Yeah. He's very talented. He's really good. No. That's really cool. While we're sort of. In this area. Of the world. I was appreciating. A lot of seeing.

[00:24:55] Gandalf continue to come into. His own. Like who we. Think of as Gandalf. So. We one. Got to see. His control. Of his own powers. Growing. And that. Really cool scene. With the Oliphant. Yeah. But also like. In the lead up. To that. Kind of seeing him. Be his slightly. Like. He is. Capable. But sometimes. Bumbling.

[00:25:25] Or at least has the appearance. Of being bumbling. So like he's. Messing with the crystal. On his staff. And kind of being a little. Silly and goofy. With that. And then like. The way he. Lost his temper. A bit with Tom. Also feels like. The Gandalf. That we. Like have known. And loved. And then by the end. Of the episode. Like he gets his hat on. Yeah. The hat. Yeah. It just really felt like. Okay. Like he has his mission. He has.

[00:25:54] His components. Of. Himself. He has his name. Game. Like. This is Gandalf. Now. From here on. And I thought that was fun. Next. He just needs a pipe. And some. Oh yeah. Some pipe weed. To really complete the picture. We need some. Farming hobbits. Who can get him that. Yeah. He'll discover it soon enough. I'm. I'm looking forward to it. I. I always enjoyed the fact that. That Gandalf's. Power.

[00:26:24] And you know. In the original movies. He didn't choose to show it all the time. He. He dressed humbly. He spoke directly with people. You know. He was. He was quick to be like. Hey I'm a wizard. I'm not subject to your laws. But. He. Was personable. And charming. And then. So that when he did decide. To wield his power. It was. All the more. Impressive. And terrifying. Yeah. Because he was so selective about it. And he lured people into.

[00:26:54] With his like sort of. I'm just a bumbling old man. Routine. And then. You know. Then he would whip out his staff. Or whatever. And be powerful. I just. I enjoyed that about him. And that's more of that same theme. That you were just talking about. Sort of. Things not always being. You know. What they seem. Based on appearances. I think. You know. Gandalf comes. Across. As more unassuming. Than he is. Yeah. Whereas someone like.

[00:27:24] Farazan. Whose bluster. Is actually not. Um. Necessarily. That powerful. Of a guy. Right. I don't know. Yeah. Or. I mean. Or like Saraband. In the original movies. Right. He like lives in this big tower. And he's all like. Nobody could talk to me. Because I'm up on high. And. And you know. Gandalf walks around. Or drives a little horse and wagon. Like he's. Yeah. He presents himself more humbly. Uh. Not unlike Tom Bombadil. Who also. Is apparently incredibly powerful. We still don't know what he is.

[00:27:54] Right. But he's like. Yeah. I'm just like taking care of some goats. And growing my vegetables. I like singing. You know. I was thinking about him. More this week. And just thinking about. What has already been discussed a lot in the show. Which is. The kind of. Differing impacts. Of perception. Of passage of time. Between elves and dwarves. And how. Elves I think can be a bit more stoic.

[00:28:24] About things. And a bit less like. I guess present with mortality. And stuff. Because they live so so long. But then if you think about Bombadil. Who is. Quote eldest. You know. The amount of time he has lived. These sort of. Idea of. Giant events. And ruinous catastrophes. You know. He's probably seen these ebbs and flows over time. And sort of like. That's why he doesn't get so drawn into it.

[00:28:54] And so he's a bit more detached. Because it seems like. You know. The daily catastrophes. That we have in our day-to-day life. Which can feel like. You know. Big. But over time. It's a day-to-day rhythm. And I think that's almost sort of. Part of Tom Bombadil. Bombadil's like detachment. From the events that are going on. I agree. It's. He's immortal. And so. He might be like. Oh. That's too bad. A lot of people are dying.

[00:29:24] Do-do-do-do-do. Garden time. Like. It just. It doesn't. Directly affect him. And he has to take. Kind of a philosophical. Interpretation. Because. You can't spend. Eternity. Being concerned. About every detail. Every day. Of every person. You'll go insane. Yeah. I hope he. He does show back up again. Later in the series. We've got. Two more seasons.

[00:29:53] I think he's done for this season. That's my guess. Yeah. But I think he will pop back in. At some point. I wouldn't be surprised. I hope so. Because he's fun. And that's a great. Rory Kinnear. Amazing actor. Yeah. He's very much. What I. Pictured. Tom Bombadil would be. He. I feel like that actor. Has really. Personified him well. For some reason. I always pictured. Tom Bombadil. As being. Like very. Slender. Really? Yeah. Like almost.

[00:30:22] Like the scarecrow. From Wizard of Oz. Kind of a. Vibe. And I don't know. If that's in the text at all. Or if that's just completely. What I made up in my own head. Doesn't really matter. Yeah. I think I. I guess I thought of him. As like a. I don't know. David the gnome. Was like a cartoon show. I used to watch as a kid. Nick Jr. In the 80s. And. That is who I pictured. As Tom Bombadil. Just much larger.

[00:30:52] That's really funny. I never. I don't even know that show. Yeah. Yeah. The elder millennials. Might. Yeah. It was a blip. Yeah. I was a little too old. For Nickelodeon. When it. Was introduced. And then. And the kids I babysat. For watch stuff. Not. That wasn't one of them. I remember watching a lot of. Count Ducula. With babysitter. Babysat kids.

[00:31:23] And. He-Man. And. Thundercats. There was a lot of Thundercats. Around then. If I recall correctly. Why don't we talk about. About Farazan. A little bit. Yeah. And. I. My. My ongoing theme. Of daddy issues. Right. I clocked that. For sure. Yeah. Big time daddy issues. In these episodes. So. First we had like. Theo. Who. At the end there. Is caught between. Like.

[00:31:52] Last father figure. Current father figure. Like. Horrible. Father son. Dynamic. They had going there. And then. We got. Anarian. And. Ellen deal. Which. Who seemed to have. A beautiful relationship. And respect. There was a lot of things. They did to demonstrate that. They like. Made sure we were fully aware. That they were father and son. That they love each other. They did a lot of like. Slapping each other on the shoulder. Kind of stuff. And then they have that whole like. Remember when we came here.

[00:32:21] To the beach as a family. So you knew that there was like. Warmth and love. And. They share a little joke about how. Isildur was like. I don't know. Incompetent at singing. I don't. They never finished that story. So. We get this beautiful picture. Of this relationship. And then we see them go together. You're the only man I trust. And they go together. To try to like. Foil this scheme. And then we get to contrast that. In our head. With Kemen and Farazan. Oh. And I. I love knowing. Kemen's backstory. A little bit now. Because.

[00:32:52] It explains so much about him. Right. That he. Always feels like he. Is not good enough. And has to suck up to Farazan. Because of the way that. You know. His background. He was. He wasn't born. In a legitimate marriage. His mother was. Implied to be a prostitute. And. And then he's all like. I. You know. I'm so grateful for that mercy. When he like. Didn't kill me. And instead killed my mother. And let me come live with him.

[00:33:22] To be treated like garbage. It's really. Fascinating. It humanized Kemen for me. I was like. Absolutely. You're still the worst. But now I understand. How you got to be the worst. And you have. He's at a crossroads now. Because he's. He's. They're captive. He. Elendil and. And Anarion have him. And. Elendil. In that. In that. Wagon. When they were traveling together. Which by the way. Was that King Aegon and Larys to you? Because it was.

[00:33:51] House of the Dragon reference. For those who haven't watched it. But. You know. They're having this like. Sort of. Interesting conversation in the wagon. And Elendil's like. What is it? He said. He said. I'm. As strange as it may seem. I'm taking a. A paternal interest in your soul. Yeah. Like what. You know. You're. You just spend all your time. Whoring yourself out. To Farazan's ambitions. And. And. Kemen is in a really interesting position now. Because he. I don't know. He could go. Either way.

[00:34:20] He could either join. With the faithful. And free himself from Farazan. Or he could continue to be a weasel. And go back to his father. But. It's more interesting to me now. Knowing. His story. Yeah. I mean. The look of sort of. Shock. On Kemen's face. He did not know how to respond. To Elendil saying that. No. Not at all. And Elendil was tempting him. With freedom. Instead of chasing.

[00:34:51] Favor. And power. With Farazan. And. Which was interesting. And honor. Yeah. And it made me think back to. The horrible scene. When Kemen killed. Elendil. In season two. When. Kemen had just witnessed. A couple of scenes. Of all of the men. Who served. Under Elendil. Like loving. And revering. And honoring him. And he was like. He's not your. Captain anymore. And they're all like.

[00:35:21] He'll always be our captain. And. Kemen. Had this look on his face then. Like I don't completely understand. What's happening here. Because he's never had someone. Like that. That he admired. And respected. And looked up to. And who was kind of paternal. He only had Farazan. Who was like. If you please me. I might tell you. What your mother said about you. Before she died. Like. Yeah. Or a good person. And. And again here. He's seeing. Like Elendil. Even when he's captured. And tied up. Is like. Being honorable. And when he killed.

[00:35:51] Valendil. Remember that. Valendil. Was gonna. Was gonna win. And Elendil. Told him to stop. And Valendil. Stopped. And walked away. And Kevin killed him. By stabbing him in the back. And there was something. On Kevin's face at the time. Where he was a little bit like. Have Elendil arrested. And let people know. He started all this trouble. But there was a look on his face. A little bit like. He was like. Like. I don't think anyone. Will ever respect me. As much as Valendil. Respected Elendil. And I don't think anyone. Would care about me. The way Elendil. Cared about Valendil.

[00:36:20] And that's not even his kid. Yeah. And I think there's. A lot of jealousy in him. When it comes to. Isildur. And Valendil. And all those other sailors. Who worked with Elendil. Because. He doesn't have anybody. That he feels that way about. Yeah. It's sad. His story is sad. Now I'm sad about him. I used to just hate him. Now it's all complicated. I know. It's the worst. I mean. I think that's what it is for me. Like Theo. I was.

[00:36:49] Fully prepped and ready. To hate all of. The human ring bearers. And. Damn. That complicated. For me. And I think. This is that same sort of thing. And. I can appreciate it. I mean. It's fun to hate. A very villainous villain. But. It's not the reality. Like people are complicated. And almost every. Person. Even who have done the most.

[00:37:18] Like terrible things. Have probably also done. Good things in their life too. Right. And they've been. Someone. Someone's loved. Along the way. And it just. I think having these. Complicated. Characters. Is more interesting. But. It makes it hard. As a viewer. Like. Yeah. Yeah. If I had. Spent some time. Thinking along these lines. I probably would have. Expected a little bit. Of this. Coming. The humanization of the.

[00:37:48] Of the Naz. Nagal. And the humanization. Of. Orc. Hemen. Because we've had. Humanization of orcs. Last season. You know. We had like an orc. With a family. And you know. Orcs who wanted peace. Orcs who just wanted personhood. They didn't want to be called orcs. They wanted to be called Uruk. They didn't want to be slaves. And. We had the. A lot of. Along the way. Personalization of Sauron. Like when Sauron. Was being. Halbrand.

[00:38:18] Yeah. There was a lot of. Of moments. In that season. Especially when you watch it again. Knowing who he is. Is. Where. You're truly moved. By the fact that he seems to. Want redemption. And want to. Opt out of. The power games. He's like. No I'll just be a blacksmith. Now. Was it genuine or not? I think. He thought it was. Yeah. You know. With narcissists. Sometimes they have good intentions. For 15 minutes.

[00:38:48] And they're genuine. They just don't last. And I think that there was part of him. That genuinely wanted to be like. No. I could just be a smith. This will be great. I'll just be a smith. And I won't be part of the power games. In Middle Earth. It'll be great. And then. You know. He gets dragged back in. And I think that the conversation he had with Galadriel. After the battle. Where he was like. There was a moment. Fighting beside you. Where I felt right. And I think that was. Genuine. In that moment. Yeah. But it's just not. His. His true nature always. Is going to take over. And it.

[00:39:17] It sure did. It's just not. But so. This is a show that has humanized evil. Or bad. Or problematic. Or whatever. Villains for us in the past. I just didn't think that they were going to take Kemin from. Innocuous. Nerdy dude. To like. I want to punch that guy in the face. To like. Aw. Like I didn't see that. I didn't see that journey coming. Yeah. Um. I can't wait to see what happens next. Between him and Elendil.

[00:39:47] Same. And this is now. At least. The second direct time. That Elendil has. Stopped his death. Because I don't think. Anarion would have. Stopped. No. Anarion was bad. Yeah. I mean they kidnapped his dad. Yeah. And. He doesn't. So Elendil now knows. That Aarion is dead. But I don't know if. So Anarion doesn't even know that yet. No. I don't think he's heard yet.

[00:40:16] And Kemin was such a jerk. To be like. Oh. Did no one tell you? It's like. You know he's on the other side of the island. You jerk. That just. Yeah. Uh. Yeah. Amazing. Amazing. Pair of scenes. Those scenes. Do you think that Isildur had any problem getting away? I thought it was interesting that they seemed to know what Aarion was up to. But that Isildur would be able to still. Sort of escape the.

[00:40:46] Yeah. Palace grounds. It's a little bit like. How did Kemin get to the other side of the island in two days when. Right. Like. I think we have to yada yada over that. Because. Um. If you think about it too hard. It really doesn't make any sense. Because like. How do they know what Aarion told them? How do they know that. That. Like they knew. They probably figured out very quickly. What she was doing in Belzegar's chambers. And that she stole the key. But in that scene where they confronted her. They didn't even say. We know you took the key.

[00:41:15] But they wanted Isildur to tell. Like they wanted that lie. As a trap. So they knew where he was going. They must have. So you would think that they would have had like a trap. Like. Maybe. That's. See at the beginning of next episode. Yeah. Him getting. Captured. Yeah. Maybe. To complicate the fact that they have Kemin. Then Farazan will be. Ha ha. I have your son. And. Yeah. Maybe. That would make sense.

[00:41:44] But does Farazan care enough about Kemin? Unclear. Yeah. This is something I don't understand. And I have. Had this question about other characters in fantasy literature. Is why is Farazan not married? And doesn't have an. Apparently an heir. Like a legitimate heir. That to the point where he like took in. You know. This prostitute's kid. That's his. Is. If. He's like a person of substance. In Numenorean society.

[00:42:14] And he has. Ambitions. For power. And now he's king. It's weird to me that he's not married. For real. I just feel like in that society that would have happened. It's like kings have to always get married so that they can have an heir. I. This question. I also have about Tywin Lannister. Why did Tywin Lannister never remarry? But. Um. That's a different show.

[00:42:42] It's just weird to me that Farazan never married. It seems like he's not interested in. In women. Like he wasn't interested in the. The like floozy chick. But last season. It seemed like he. Wanted Muriel. Not just for her position. Like. They're cousins though aren't they? Yeah. But I don't know if that matters. Yeah. In the scene where he's helping her pick out her outfit. You know. And he's like the red or the white. You know. The past or the future. Yeah. Anyway. Um. He was like.

[00:43:11] Weirdly handsy with her. And like. Overly intimate. I thought. To the point where I was like. Is he into her? Like. Is he into Muriel? Has he been holding out for her all this time? Is that why he's not married? Is he married? This is all speculation. I think that was just a control. Make her as uncomfortable as possible. Show her I'm in the position of power. Maybe. Ugh. I hate him. Ugh. He's so gross. Ugh. At least he's like not redeemable at this point. They better not tell us some sad story. I don't want it.

[00:43:41] I want to hate him. Yeah. I saw. Um. There's these. Uh. On Prime. There are these little like featurettes. Called the forging of episode. For each episode. And they had an interview. With the actor who plays Farazan. He was like. Laughing. And he was like. Yeah. I'm. I'm standing in front of this. At the head of this carriage. Throwing out coins. With my own face on them. Like. Like. He was like. I'm the worst. Yeah. Yeah. I don't think there's any redeeming. For Farazan. On the horizon.

[00:44:11] He basically would have to like. Single handedly defeat Sauron. For people to. Think he's a good guy. At this point. Yeah. Yeah. And he's much more likely to be like. Where's my ring? Right. Um. Farazan. Ugh. Um. But. Uh. We did get a note from. Um. And when about Anarion. At one point. She was like. Woo. Anarion. And it's like. Yeah. That line of people. Elendil.

[00:44:41] Anarion. Isildur. On down to Aragorn. Like. Yeah. That is some handsomeness genes in there. You still wear Aragorn. I think they cast. These ancestors very well. Yeah. To be. That is a line of Aragorn. A handsome group of people. Like. And. And. Aarion. Quite beautiful too. So. It's a. It's just a very attractive family tree. Yeah. Impressive to me. I mean. I know it's TV. Everybody's good looking.

[00:45:15] Um. So. That's most of my like. Major. Stuff. I didn't have a lot of points to make. But I had. Oh. I do have another thing. Okay. I was. I was about to be very surprised. That you don't have another thing. Because. Yeah. There's two other things actually. We haven't talked a lot. Yeah. I think. While we're still sort of like. Talking about Numenor. Um. I guess. We could talk about what I think must. Will be hopefully in the next couple episodes. Which is our.

[00:45:45] Elven envoy. Yeah. To Numenor. Yeah. Um. Gil Gallad and Elrond. That is a powerful team. Yeah. Right. Um. I don't know that there's a lot more to say about it. Other than I'm just sort of. Excited. I'm excited to see Elrond go on the emotional journey. Of sort of reckoning with Numenor. I'm hoping we maybe get. I'm not sure that from the show.

[00:46:14] I have fully gleaned. The full like understanding of his complex feelings around. His brother and Numenor. Um. And so I'm hoping maybe we get some more. Like I don't know if while he's traveling with Gil Gallad. He might talk about it more. Do you agree with that Penny? Like do you still find some. Questions around that? I am getting the vibe. And it's.

[00:46:43] I don't think there's been anything expressed about this. On the show. And I. I don't know the lore like Anwen does. But I get the vibe that. Elrond has not been to Numenor. If ever. But definitely not since his brother. Like founded it as a. People and chose mortality. Like I don't think he's been there this whole time. I don't think he wants to know. I think he. Kind of resents Numenor. Yeah. For. For what it represents. I mean.

[00:47:12] This is a guy who's. Lost his parents. Because. The Valar. Rewarded them with never having to like come home to him again. I mean. That's not what the reward was. But that was the effect of the reward. Right. His father's literally a star. Like he could never get back to his father. And his mother was given some other reward where she never comes back to Middle Earth. And then his brother's like I choose mortality. It's like his people keep leaving him. And if I were him.

[00:47:40] I would be torn between being like he made a choice. And there's nobility in it. And he founded this whole people. And that's something to be proud of. And also being like I hate those people. They took my brother away from me. Yeah. Man. I think. Like. I do hope we get more exploration of this. And I think. You talking about it just now. Made me realize how much this compounds.

[00:48:09] Arwen's future choices. For him. More so than just that she was his daughter. That this has been a theme he's been wrestling with. For thousands of years. People keep leaving him. That's brutal. Yeah. And he's. You know. He's so smart. And well read. And thoughtful. And philosophical. That I'm sure he falls prey to what a lot of smart people fall prey to. Which is intellectualizing their emotions. Right.

[00:48:38] So he spends a lot of time thinking about. What Elros did. And was it right. And do I understand what his reasons were. Without actually feeling what he feels about it. And I wonder if we're going to get to see a little bit of raw. Emotion from Elrond coming in the next couple episodes. I hope so. It would be nice to see that side of him. I agree. I enjoy his character a lot. I. I like this actor.

[00:49:07] I think I was surprised at the casting. Based on the. You know. Version of Elrond that we see. In the movies. But I've really. Really. Grown to just. Adore this portrayal. And. It's just been fun. To see. A young Elrond. And. I think this would be a really. Neat. Piece. For us to see.

[00:49:35] Especially if he does open up some of his emotions. Because. You're right. He always sort of relies on. Calm. Intellect. And it's very rare that we see much emotion. In whatever iteration of Elrond we've gotten. So. Hopefully. This will bring that out. Yeah. And he can talk to Gilgadady about it. I know. They're going to have some bonding time on. Yeah. Which is very exciting. The idea of those two hotties.

[00:50:05] Hotties being on a ship together. It's very appealing to me. I. I thought it was really funny. When he shows up at the battle. Right. First of all. There's this really weird conversation. Between Kirden and. And Gilgad about like. Well. These people are dead. But. You know. It's. It makes. The ones who are alive more precious. Or whatever. It was just. I don't know. They were a little too philosophical. About a field full of dead elves. But. When that one woman comes up. And she's like. You have to come and see this. I thought it was so funny. That she wasn't like.

[00:50:34] It's Elrond. The king's herald. You. He's here. And she's like. You have to see something. Which was. Right. But anyway. She's like. There were. At least a dozen. Close to a dozen orcs. Dead around him. And he's like. It was 16. Was so funny to me. Yeah. That was funny. I feel like. We just keep getting. I mean. It's just been twice. But we keep getting. These clips of. Gilgad and Kirden. Looking very like. Distinguished.

[00:51:03] But with a little bit of like. Battle dust on their face. Yeah. Gilgad's hair was. Oh I had this vision. And oh. We must go with hope. And like. It's a little. Silly. So again. Another reason. I'm excited. To see Gilgad. Sort of. Go do something. Other than have these very like. Hoity-toity conversations. On a battlefield. So funny. Yeah. His hair was like. A little bit. Unsleek and shiny.

[00:51:33] And I was like. Oh my god. He's human. And then I was like. No he's not. He's elven. But. He is a king. I'm a little sad. That they're leaving. Without Kirdan. Because I love this actor. Who plays Kirdan. And I want. Yeah. I want to see him do more. I'll just have to go back. And re-watch the last season of Foundation. I was writing in my notes. And I put. He says they must go in person. And then I put. In elf? Question mark. Right. Do you see you go in person? In elf?

[00:52:04] Yeah. That's confusing. I don't know what the. What the grammar is there. Neither. There. Um. It's so funny. Yeah. That's something to look forward to. And then having them in the same room with Farazan. That's a lot of. Oh. Really. Like. Big. Beautiful hair. Yeah. A lot of. Just a lot of hair in general. Just a lot. Just so much hair. Um. Should we talk about the drama going on over in Khazad-dum? Oh.

[00:52:34] My gosh. Yeah. Yes. Lead. Lead us over there. It's a lot. It's a lot. So. So Thrain. And Deezah. We find out a little bit about their history. And. Um. It's a one night stand. And he is holding it over her head. He's like. Why don't I tell Duren about it? I don't. If it didn't mean anything. How come you never told him? And. I was really pleased to see her immediately. Go tell Duren. Yeah.

[00:53:04] And be like. I'm calling your bluff on this one. I think that if she had been like. You wouldn't dare. Or something like that. Thrain would have told it to him in the middle of that fight. And things would have ended up. Pretty much exactly how they ended up. But. But I still respect her for going to him. Same. And telling him. And the way they talked about it. I thought. Was further evidence of what I've liked so long about their relationship. Is that they were like. She's like. I have to tell you something. Sit down. And he's like. Oh. That's how I know it's bad. And then.

[00:53:33] She says it. And he asks a series of questions. And then he's like. Yeah. I have my own regrets about that fight. All right. We don't have to talk about it ever again. And it's just this like. Assessment. Based on the totality of their relationship. Yeah. That. She's like. I think we're stronger than this. Am I right? And he's like. Yeah. You're right. We're stronger than this. Let's move on. We got to beat Thrain. And I was so happy in that moment. And then. His kid. Like.

[00:54:03] Ugh. Really misinterpreted what he saw. And then. Duren. Like. Let it. Get him. Upset. Like. So upset. That he. He. He basically threw the fight. Or like. Ruined his chances. I mean. He apparently did what he has done in every encounter with Thrain. Since they were young. Exactly what Disa calls it. At the beginning of the episode. That. Yeah. Something happens. It gets under his skin.

[00:54:33] He acts brash. And loses. Because he didn't keep a cool head. And we saw it play out. Like. Exactly. And he's only alive. Because. Thrain. Is. A total crap head. But I think he does. Underneath it all. Have some remaining love. For his brother. It won't stop him from stepping over him. But it stopped him from using the sharp end of his axe. In that. Last moment. But. Great. I'm grateful for that. But.

[00:55:02] It was so funny because. You have one sibling. Right? Oh no. I am one of four. One of four. Okay. So. Same. I'm one of eight. And. There's nobody in the world that can bother you like a sibling. Oh. Right. Right. Like. You can be. A mature. Accomplished. Professional person. And your sibling. Does or says something. That's the same thing they've been doing since you were six. And it makes you crazy.

[00:55:32] Yep. It was just such a relatable moment. It frustrated me because Duren had been warned that something like this would happen. And then he fell for it immediately. Because it came from his son. And he wasn't. He wasn't braced for his son to reveal something to him like that. Right. Right. But. It was also kind of stupid of him to be like. Because he says like what do you mean. And we don't get to hear exactly what the son says. But he demonstrates like that.

[00:56:01] He saw Thrain like touch Disa's face or whatever. And Disa sees it and is like oh no. Oh no. No. No. And it's not. She doesn't have time to intervene. And. But like even exactly what the kid described to him. Should not have been enough to make Duren go crazy like that. Right. That was. That was some outsized. Volatile temper. When he should have been like fully in the mode of like we're not. We're not going to do that. Right.

[00:56:28] Even in that moment he should have been like I'll channel my anger into kicking his butt. But he really didn't. No. It's sad. It's very sad. I really want to know where the rings are hidden. Because like not knowing makes me not know how hard it's going to be for Thrain to find them. Yeah. I hope they're somewhere really really clever. Yeah. I don't think they will be.

[00:56:58] No. I think Thrain's going to find them. I think so also. I wonder if the dwarf rings like the one ring have some agency of wanting to be found. Hmm. Because in the. I don't know if it's really apparent in the movies but in the books it's talked about a couple of different times that the one ring like chose to leave Gollum's finger.

[00:57:24] So that it could be found by someone else because it was tired of living under the mountain and it chose to slip off Isildur's finger. Because it didn't want him to be its master. Yeah. I don't know if these have that same draw or not. Yeah. I'd be curious to know. And they're probably. If Thrain. I love Thrain but he's not really as smart as I would like him to be. He probably hid all of them in one place.

[00:57:52] I mean the saving grace is that surely Disa had a role. Hopefully. If Disa hid them I believe they're somewhere that's going to be hard to find. If Durin hid them I worry. Yeah. I mean it seems inevitable that Thrain is going to find them and distribute them to the other dwarf lords. That seems to be his goal and I have a feeling that's where the story is going but I don't want it to go there.

[00:58:22] Yeah. It's so funny. I think it has to. Yeah. We all know where this story goes right. We've all seen the first 10 minutes of Fellowship of the Ring when we see the great battle and we see how powerful Sauron has become at that point and how he's like taking control of most of Middle Earth. So we all know that's coming. And yet every step of the way towards it I'm like no no no no no no no no no no. Please don't do that. Like don't go there. It was so nice before. I mean yeah. Yeah.

[00:58:52] I feel like I even do that when I rewatch like the same movies though right. Like. Yeah. I still catch myself so. It's hard not to. Yeah. You. You hope this time the characters will just maybe choose a little differently. Even though it's nonsensical. Yeah. Can you imagine if one time you were watching a movie you'd seen before and they do choose differently? You'd be like. Did I have a stroke? Like. Or what's that? Oh. Yeah.

[00:59:21] Like I don't know the Berenstain. Berenstain. Bear. Oh right. What's that called? When like you think you have a memory of something being one way and then it changes. Yeah. Like how. I can't remember that phenomenon but. Like. Like lots of people in this country think that Sinbad was in a movie version of Shazam where he played Shazam. And this like never happened. But like I remember it. Same. Yeah. So weird. Yeah. It's like a glitch in the Matrix. I don't. Right. Yeah.

[00:59:51] It's so weird. But it'd be kind of cool if something that I really really loved like this. If there was a glitch in the Matrix. And like. And suddenly I could watch it anew. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean maybe. Maybe when I get old enough. I'll just start forgetting a few things. And then maybe those last years of life you get to experience things anew again. You could just watch. I think I'm romanticizing. I'm romanticizing something that's not very romantic. Over and over again. Hey why not?

[01:00:21] Yeah. It could happen. Could be a positive. Yeah. Oh the dwarves. So one thing that kind of bugged me about the dwarf storyline is just that like. I don't know. I've always thought of Tolkien as being. A universe of the sort of Middle Earth universe of being a place where. Romance and love stories and. And romantic drama.

[01:00:52] Didn't really exist. But I guess in the in the legends there's plenty of romantic drama. It's just the main Lord of the Rings and Hobbit books that don't have a lot of romance in them. Yeah. Which I can't. Like. It just felt kind of soap opera. I think it's something I liked. When I first read the books. Especially like. I was a young child when I first read the books. I think I liked that there wasn't romance. And I'm still not a huge like romance reader. But.

[01:01:23] I have been enjoying the romantic storylines that we finally are getting. In this series. I mean I have been a big fan of Disa and Durin's marriage this whole time. I guess I just felt like this like. Dun dun dun. She slept with the brother. Was just a little. I don't know. It seemed below her or something. And below Tolkien. I think for me. Like if it had been elves. I think I would have felt differently.

[01:01:52] But dwarves feel so. I don't know. More similar to humans in their imperfections. Of character. Yeah. They're very passionate right there. And so I feel like I could see it. Happening. You know. It didn't feel. It didn't totally take me out of. Who I sort of feel dwarves are. Yeah. That's fair.

[01:02:21] I'm just very. I'll be. I'm really interested to see where this goes. And. And how. Durin responds when he wakes up. Right. Like where do. Where do we go from here with him. And does he stay. There. Well. Like does he continue to live there. Under his brother's rule. It didn't really seem. Like is his brother really interested in ruling there.

[01:02:49] He said he would give it up. If Disa could get him the rings. Yeah. And we know he's in league with the Naznagul. If not Sauron himself. So. Maybe he just takes power. Gets the rings. And then peaces out. Maybe. But that doesn't seem. Like an. I don't know. Yeah. That's maybe not the. Yeah. That's like storyline. Duran. Is Duran going to stay there. And have some kind of resistance movement. Is he going to.

[01:03:17] Is there going to be some kind of cat and mouse game. About trying to find the rings. I don't know where we go from here. And is Disa going to be like. You're an idiot. Because. That's. Not. Like nothing happened. You're. That was just your brother being a jerk. Like that. Nothing happened in that moment. That our son misinterpreted. Yeah. Will Duran wake up mad at her. And be isolated completely. Right. Is the story. The rest of the season. Going to be. Duran and Disa on the rocks.

[01:03:48] Yeah. Which would be so frustrating. Yeah. Or. Are we going to think. Duran and Disa are on the rocks. And Disa. Is actually going to go try to use. Her. Sort of position. With the rain. To their advantage. And then we get the big reveal. That would be clever. Yeah. And Thrain would totally fall for it. Yeah. I could see that.

[01:04:17] And I could see them doing it in a way. Where they even try to trick us. To think that Disa and Duran are still. On the rocks. Although they haven't been trying to trick us. With things much. They have. This season. They've done a lot with. Marnuk. Where it kept being like. He's with us. He's not with us. He's with us. He's not with us. Even like. After the. They first start the prison break. When like. He and Arondir. Kill the other. Right. And then Arondir's like.

[01:04:47] You were too good at pretending. General. You told us you were a lowly orc. And you're not a lowly orc. Like. Even in that moment. I was like. Is he about to. To you know. Betray them. And then when. When Sauron shows up. And he's like. I was just. It was just a jive. I'm with you. The whole time. And so. And everyone's looking at each other. Like wait. Is he? Is he? We don't know. And then he's like. Psych. And he lets out all the prisoners. That was hilarious. Yeah. But they. They were playing with us. The whole way through that whole prison break. Right.

[01:05:18] In a lot of ways. It's not just with. The back and forth. Of. I. I keep wanting to call him. Muck duck. I don't know if anyone. Watches the office. There's a line. Where. Dwight. K. Is a more. Or K. Is a less aggressive. Letter than R. Because we don't call it. We don't call it. Muck duck. We call it murder. And so. For some reason. Like. I can only call this work. Muck duck.

[01:05:47] That's really funny. Anyways. But anyway. Muck. Muck. Beyond just him. I mean. Even. The way they did the reveal. For. Celeborn. That he was with Galadriel. The way they sort of like. Played all around. Them finding that out. I thought was a little bit mad thing. It was. It was. Not completely believable to me. That. Erendir and Galadriel. Have been fighting together.

[01:06:16] And at war together. For five years. And he doesn't know the name of her husband. Right. She. She likes him well enough. As a friend. To tell him that she's lonely. Something we haven't really heard her say. To anyone else. But she's never mentioned. Her husband's name. She's a renowned. General. Erendir knew about. And her husband. Was also like. A renowned. Elven soldier.

[01:06:47] It was all a little hard for me. Yeah. To say. That they didn't know him. And I was just. Yelling. Say Galadriel. Say it. Like what? Yeah. Kill him. They had that. Sort of comedy scene. Where he's like. You guys do what you want to do. I'm out. Right. And they're like. Well I'm not leaving without Galadriel. He was like. Oh. Then I'm back in. Like he doesn't say to them. Galadriel. That's my wife. Or anything like that. He just turns around. And he's back in the group. And I was like. That was. That felt sitcom-y. But then it was. Very quickly overshadowed.

[01:07:17] By what happened after. We did get the beautiful. Moment of their. Reunion. And he had the advantage. Of having a few minutes. Of knowing she was in the building. So when he came upon her. He wasn't like. In complete shock. But she was in no way. Prepared for that. Right. And he came across her. In such a beautiful. Sort of. It almost looked the same. Except she was in an actual battle.

[01:07:46] But the way he first met her. Sort of like dancing. Dance fighting on her own. Through the forest. I thought that was. Well done. Little mirror. Yeah. And then the dropped sword. In slow motion. Was a little cheesy. But I'll let them have it. Because it was beautiful. To see them. Reunite. And to see the look on her face. She didn't even say anything. She didn't say his name. She just was like. Staring at him. And then. You know. Touched his face. And. I just. I found that very. Moving.

[01:08:15] More than if they had like. Hugged. And cried. And kissed. The. The stillness. Of her just wanting to look at him. It felt right. Yeah. Yeah. It was beautiful. And I'm glad they're back together. I'm happy to see them back together. I hope we don't end up in like. Soap opera land. That's my only worry. Is that like. Is it going to be like all about their romance now? Or. Yeah. I don't think so. From. Totally not. Some of the press. I think it's going to be more interesting than that. But.

[01:08:46] I. I cannot complain one tiny bit about Jamie Campbell Bower's performance as Celeborn. He's fantastic. Yeah. He's like a little bit funny. And dry. And he's got that amazing sort of like deep voice. And then his. His like elfie looking face. He's perfect for this role. Like he might be an elf in real life. I think. Yeah. It's possible. It's possible. He's also an amazing musician. Like he's. Oh really? Very talented person.

[01:09:16] It's so funny after seeing him as Vecna. Like Vecna was so gross and scary. And then. My wife. He's just like. Pure hero character. My wife is still having a really hard time. Like accepting that he's not actually a bad guy. Because of Stranger Things. Because of Vecna. Yeah. That's really funny. I don't think Celeborn's a bad guy. But it would be interesting if. His like thousands of years of imprisonment. Have done some stuff to him.

[01:09:46] Yeah. And that that starts to come up. And that they have to go through a readjustment period of their relationship. Because. Wow. They've been apart. And they've had such vastly different experiences in those thousands of years. He's been in prison trying to escape over and over again. And she has been on like a revenge mission against Sauron this whole time. And then like sort of kind of started falling for him for just a second. Yeah.

[01:10:21] Yeah. Like jealous moment. It was like Celeborn. And he didn't say it. But the look on his face was like he's still alive. I thought I didn't have any competition. He had a lot of valuable stuff in those two cells across from each other. Yeah. In this fortress he was ignoring. Yeah. Seriously. In the north. Just the north. The name of the fortress cracks me up too. Gundabad is just a really funny name. Gundabad. I really like that. That's great.

[01:10:51] Right at the end when they were on the roof waiting once again for an eagle to come in clutch. Aaron Deer, the door hasn't broken yet. And Aaron Deer turns and says, Lady Galadriel, you must away. And she just looks at him like, what are you talking about? When do I run from a fight? And also work these stories up. Where am I going to away to when the eagle hasn't gotten there yet?

[01:11:20] Did you think when they did go to jump on the eagle that the, I'm calling it a dragon, but the fell beast, did you think that he was going to swoop down and like chase them or snatch the eagle? Yeah. I thought before the eagle got to them that the eagle was a goner, that this fell beast was going to come. As soon as she said it's like the prince of eagles, I was like, oh no. Yeah. Yeah. I fully expected at least to see it try.

[01:11:52] But I guess that wasn't necessary for the plot. So I thought that them like diving off the wall and then falling and the eagle grabbing them in its claws was like both awesome and corny. Like I loved it, but I also was like, that's kind of goofy looking. Right. But like, I don't know. Some of this has to be a little goofy because it is like, you know, I think all of Tolkien's writing is both serious and light and silly and dramatic.

[01:12:20] And so I think it kind of makes sense for it to be a little ridiculous that two elves left off a mountain and were caught in the claws of a giant eagle. Like that's ridiculous, right? Yeah. But it was also really cool. It was awesome. Yeah. It's funny because the Lord of the Rings and all of these stories are also at times like really scary horror monster movies. Right. Like some of these creatures, like the fell beasts were so gross and creepy.

[01:12:49] And like when Sauron's like, they need live food, like, and throws that orc over the side of the balcony for his fell beast to eat. I was like, oh God, they're so creepy and gross. But like you, in my head, when I think about like the Lord of the Rings, I picture the fellowship, right? I picture the hobbits and I picture Aragorn and I picture Legolas and Gimli and how they became friends.

[01:13:14] I forget about the like, you know, she lobbed the spider and the, whatever the creature is that's outside Kazad or Moria and tries to like suck them into the swamp. And like, I forget about those things until they show something like horrible, like the fell beast on the screen. And then I'm like, oh yeah, that's right. There's lots of monsters in the middle of it. Yeah. It's a dangerous world out there, Mr. Frodo. Really gross, disgusting, slimy, squirmy, wormy looking.

[01:13:44] So we found out how Sauron like knows so much of what's going on. And it's not that he can necessarily see all things, but he has this diabolical, magical crow network with his, you know, ring bearers. And I don't know if it's just them who can send him messages via bird or if other of his orc, like captains have another way to do that.

[01:14:13] Or if the birds eventually just start being his spies directly. The scene where the crow reaches him and they're all fluttering around him, whispering at him was again, horrible and beautiful. Yeah. Yeah. It was cool. Really creepy. But also I was like, oh, that's how he knows who Gandalf is. But then I was like, is it though? Like how does, we don't, we don't completely have an explanation for how he knows about Gandalf and by name too.

[01:14:40] It's not like he even was like, I'll deal with that, you know, stranger. Yeah. I mean, the quadrum who came to him knew who Gandalf was. Did they know his name or did they just say there's one who is opposing us? And then I think they said something vague. Like there's, and there's another who is opposing us and, and Sauron's like, I'll deal

[01:15:10] with Gandalf, which is why, which is why all of us were like, I don't know his name. You're right. I agree that it's, it's something related to this crow network of spies, but we don't know exactly which spy might've told him that. It has to be more than just. Cause there's not even nine of them yet. Right. He still has like two or three rings left in the box.

[01:15:34] I think when he got Theo, there were five. And so Theo would have taken one, which would be four. And I won't say it cause I don't want it to be a spoiler, but I think we know where at least three of them might be going. So I think there's just like one unaccounted for additional Nazna goal that he needs to create.

[01:16:03] Like unless he did this episode. Or in between. Off screen. He'll have, he'll have all of them. Um, I, the one, I have one complaint about, about Theo in that final scene. I felt like there was something about the way his costume was structured and fitted that made him look like a little kid in an adult's clothing. And I don't know if that was intentional. Yeah.

[01:16:32] Like they stack on top of each other. Yeah. To like rob a bank as an adult or something. It was too big for him. And he was like swallowed up by it. But I don't know if that was intentional to emphasize his extreme youth. Like, I mean, when we meet the Nazgul in Lord of the Rings, they've been alive for, or dead or whatever they are for thousands of years and, and they're wraiths. But at this point, they're still in their like full physical bodies.

[01:16:58] And the other ones that we've seen, the other three are all like, you know, like middle-aged men. I, I sort of wondered all of them feel like a little, like oddly outsized, like a little larger than life. It's hard to tell exactly because they've been around a small elf like Galadriel or like amongst the dwarves.

[01:17:25] But I was wondering if sort of part of putting the ring on, we know it healed a lot about the ones like skin and physical appearance and give some strength. I almost wondered if it sort of makes them just like grow a few inches, like, like almost like drinking some end drought. They just got, they just stretched up a little bit. And so. Maybe it hasn't taken a defect in Theo yet and he'll grow into his costume. He just looked, it looked too big for him.

[01:17:55] Maybe. And in a way that was kind of awkward, but it also, because of that kind of emphasized his youth. Yeah. That he was like out of his league sort of doing this too. Like he looked like a little kid. He really did. Like he looked so grown up before he put this on, but then putting this on made him look younger again. I looked it up. That actor is 5'10".

[01:18:24] And our own dear, Ismael Cruz Cordova is like 5'7 and 3 quarters, which I love the specificity. So he's taller than, than, than Aaron dear or than. Yeah. But not like terribly tall for a man. Um, the scenes when the, um, on the road trip, when the, when the, uh, Nazna Ghul catch up with, with our heroes was such a clear and direct homage to the scene in Fellowship of the Ring

[01:18:53] when the Nazgul is hunting the hobbits or looking for the one ring. I just thought it was really funny that it was in broad daylight. I felt like that was a very beautiful scene, but I had a lot of problems with it. And it, it was, we expect that these Nazna Ghul have heightened abilities and senses, but

[01:19:18] I think even a typical human would be able to smell an orc at that range. And we know from orcs that elves have a strong smell to them. And so I would think with the additional strengthening of abilities that there was even a chance that they would have smelled the elves at that range. I mean, they were right over them.

[01:19:47] I just had a hard time believing all of it. Beautiful and cool, but like, was that really the way out of that situation? You guys distracted these like beings, enslaved beings of evil. Like they were like, Ooh, a butterfly. Ooh, lots of butterflies. And then like, they were like, I guess then there couldn't possibly be elves here. Because butterflies are acting weird. Like. Yeah.

[01:20:14] Like what better explanation for butterfly behavior like that than elves are here. Like I'm trying not to nitpick, but, and again, like it was a pretty scene, but I just. Yeah. And I was, I watched it and I was like, why wasn't that as scary as it was when it was happening to the hobbits? And first of all, it's because that's like an orc and two warriors instead of four terrified, very small hobbits. But also because it wasn't at night.

[01:20:42] And because the, the Nazna Ghul just don't have the same terrifying presence that they did in, in the Fellowship of the Ring movie where they were like these like, yeah, creepy hollow. They're just terrifying. Yeah. Like heavy breathing and. And again, the hissing. The hobbits are so small.

[01:21:07] I did think at the beginning when, is it, Kamul, when he grabbed the dark wizard's staff, like that shriek that led out very much reminded me of the shrieks that the Nazgul do later when they are. That was so interesting that he had the power to just be like, no, your power is not going to work here. Against one of the Maiar.

[01:21:34] That's like the dark wizard is now where it's confirmed. He's the same being as Gandalf and Sauron. As Gandalf, yeah. I think, I think that at some point, Anwen told me that the eagles are actually Maiar as well. And so are Balrogs. Yeah. Yeah. I think that's right about the eagles. I know it's right about Balrogs. I guess they don't all have the same powers. It's like mutants in the X-Men universe.

[01:22:05] There's like levels or something. But yeah, the ring has given this human person comparable, if not more power to a wizard. That's so much power. Yes, but distracted by butterflies. But still distracted by butterflies. It's a strange juxtaposition. I'm not sure what to do with that.

[01:22:32] So I think it's really interesting that both Kamul and Theo were in positions of subjugation, slavery, oppression when they went before Sauron. And Kamul sent there by the dark wizard as a messenger and Theo seemingly on his own motivation to fight Numenor. But they were like given this opportunity to be slaves for a different master.

[01:23:01] And they were like, oh, that's more power. I'll take it. But like, I would think that if you had been enslaved and you have any chance to not be enslaved, you would pick that over even like a more powerful slave position. But maybe that's just the way my brain works. I mean, people move up the corporate ladder all the time, Penny. You enslave yourself for more money and power. That's exactly what it is. Gross.

[01:23:32] Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I'm being like slightly dramatic. But it is kind of true. It's like, it's like, it's like Kamul went from one tech company to a more powerful tech company to help with their rolling out of their AI program. Anyway.

[01:23:59] But in secret, they made a third AI tech company to rule them all. Sorry. It's not that big of a stretch to make this illusion because these tech companies are obsessed with Lord of the Rings. There's a reason why Sam Altman named his company Palantir. Like, he was like, that's cool technology. I want to be like the evil beings in Lord of the Rings. Like, he basically set himself up for this comparison.

[01:24:26] So, I'm just going to not feel bad about that. But I just thought it was really interesting that there's like themes of slavery throughout the story because the orcs are enslaved and then they get unenslaved and they're under Adar's control. But it's like more of a like benign father kind of a deal. But then he doesn't want them to be re-enslaved by Sauron. But because he wants that so badly, he ends up putting them in a position to get re-enslaved by Sauron.

[01:24:54] So, there's just a lot of people being controlled in the story. I think generally I'm anti-slavery and I think Tolkien is as well. I really enjoyed the humanization of orcs. The story has really touched me over the past couple of seasons. I loved Adar. I thought he was such an interesting character. And then having Marnuk, first of all, be clever and tricksy is fun. That's just fun.

[01:25:23] But then the poem scene. And the fact that Galadriel was like, is that a poem? Like, are you writing a poem? And he's like, oh. I love the way he says it. It's just a fastening of words. What's a poem? He doesn't even know what a poem is. And then she makes him recite it. And then even Erendir is like, that's pretty good for an orc. Or he even says uruk, I think. Yeah. Pretty good for an orc. Yeah. It wasn't bad. Yeah. I have it. I wrote it down. Yeah.

[01:25:54] I did too. He fell among the rotted leaves below a night sky painted black, a fellow lost that no one grieves and none can ever bring him back. And then later Galadriel finishes it. But I might find him if I try for all that I must do is die. Not bad. No. It is sad. I like it.

[01:26:19] He was right that it was sad that his buddy was just like left there to die in the rot or to rot. I thought it was really ridiculous of Galadriel to let him drag a body across a battlefield and then just leave it where he had dragged it to. Like, that's such a clear sign for someone to follow. Like, she is a tracker. It was not smart. She hunted Sauron through the northern wastes and all that other stuff. Like, she would have been like, now people are going to know we've been here. We have to cover our tracks.

[01:26:49] But I digress. Yeah. I'm sad that Marnok got killed. I enjoyed him for four episodes and I was hoping to see some more of him. But his story was a little bit done. Yeah. And Arandir came around on him. Yeah. Yeah. I'm going to miss him. I enjoyed it.

[01:27:17] I thought it was a cute storyline. I think it had really nice references to Sam Frodo and Gollum's little journey, which was nice. I think it hit that theme that we've talked about quite extensively this episode of, you know, not judging a book by its cover. And like, I think we should take a moment for the cute little top knot that he wore. I really loved that.

[01:27:47] And also just for the actor, I think he did a great job. I think not only, you know, the dialogue was certainly not the only thing that kept us guessing on his character. It was a lot of the expressions that he was able to make, even through kind of a ridiculous amount of makeup. I think he still did a fantastic job of having really big emotional face reactions to parts

[01:28:15] of the story that were, I think, intentionally difficult to parse apart for that character. So no, it's very fun. He'll be missed. I liked it last season. I liked Marnuk. I hope we get another like featured Uruk in the future. They're pretty great. And just, yeah.

[01:28:38] Now I want to know like more about what happened to them fully after the end of Lord of the Rings. Because I never really cared about it. I didn't even wonder like, oh, are they all going to get killed? Are they going to get imprisoned? Are they going to get, you know, like deported? Like what's going to happen? I didn't care. Now they're humanized a bit more.

[01:29:08] They're not just mindless creatures. I really loved it when he was, you know, he was baiting Arondir and Galadriel's like, if you seek death, I know a quicker way. And he's like, his temper is going to get us in trouble when we get inside the prison. And she's like, oh, I already thought there was more to you than meets the eye. But like, you're baiting him on purpose. And for like a rational, thoughtful reason, I never would have guessed that.

[01:29:35] The look on her face was like, I keep being surprised by these Uruks. I enjoyed that he was smart in addition to being like cheeky and funny. It's like last season, there was that one orc engineer that was like a, like everyone loved that guy. It was like, he's the one who designed the war, like siege engines. Like he was like, orcs had engineers.

[01:30:06] It's been wild. Yeah. I think this show going into some orc storylines was not something I expected to see in a, Tolkien story and I didn't expect to like it so much. And it's been fun. All right. Now I'm done with all my major points. I am too. I had a couple of quick notes.

[01:30:35] One, I saw somewhere a long time ago that one of the showrunners said that this season was going to be the Empire Strikes Back season. And I didn't really think about it very much at the time, but now that we're in it and we've had two main character deaths and it's dark, it's like dark. And I'm like, oh yeah, it is the Empire Strikes Back season and it makes perfect sense. And I hope that that doesn't mean we were going to get Ewoks in season five.

[01:31:03] But I do hope that by the end of season five, things are looking up like they were at the end of Return of the Jedi. I mean, bringing up Star Wars is kind of ironic, I think, because Theo's story really gave a lot of Darth Vader to me. And the outfits they wear are very Darth Vader. And in the... Right.

[01:31:31] I feel like you could definitely play the Vader theme as Theo Klompson. And also when they're waved in the movies, they breathe like Darth Vader. I imagine that that's not an entirely accidental similarity there. I mean, heavy breathing is just kind of creepy. And also like big scary black hoods and cloaks and helmets. It's like, that's just bad guy 101.

[01:32:00] They seem to have developed a specific sound effect for when Galadriel gets a premonition from her ring. It's like a sort of a metallic tingle sound. And she looks at the ring. And then her eyes sort of narrow. And she's like, they're coming or whatever it is that she says. So now I sort of listen out for that sound effect. That's it. Yeah. I don't think I have anything else.

[01:32:28] Well, with that, we're going to take a little break. And we will be right back. Articles. Veronica, start us off. All right.

[01:32:57] So this is from Variety. And it's called It's Hotter Than Mordor on set for The Rings of Power Season 3, where dwarf beards are falling off under a UK heat wave. This is by Alex Rittman. British heat waves and massive, thick dwarven beards perhaps unsurprisingly don't mix well together. We're inside a soundstage at Shepard and Studios in late June for Season 3 of Prime Video's Lord of the Rings Rings of Power.

[01:33:25] And with mercury levels topping 90 degrees and wildfire alerts across greater London, the residents of the dwarf kingdom of Khazad-dûm are facing a dastardly new villain, Sweat. Yeah. Ooh, and all that makeup. Oh, man. Eddie Morrison's beard suddenly peeled off in a close-up yesterday, notes hair and makeup designer Flora Moody. We're really trying to keep things on, but it's a struggle. Everyone's just sweating so much.

[01:33:54] While few may have foreseen an early summer heat wave such as this, Moody hasn't exactly helped matters. To reflect Season 3 jumping ahead five years after Season 2, she upped the volume of on-screen hair considerably. I think this is one of the hairiest shows, she suggests. As a result, the dwarf beards, made of yak tail hair, quite itchy apparently, are bulkier, longer, and often more elaborately plated.

[01:34:24] Crucially, they're heavier, so when the glue holding them in place mixes with sweat, they're more liable to slip off. When you're getting somebody into a thick layer of rubber and then covering them in really heavy leather costumes, they're just walking saunas, says Barry Gower, who, alongside his wife Sarah Gower, has overseen the creation of the thousands of body parts being used across the show. We're probably one of the most irritating departments for the actors and supporting artists,

[01:34:54] because we spend the entire day walking around and prodding their faces to try to prevent things from peeling off them. Oof, that sounds brutal to be dressed in that heat. Yak hair beards. It makes them more impressive now that I've read this. No. And there's more to the article in the link in the show notes. It goes on to talk about how hard it is to make the elves look like they're cool and unbothered. Oh my gosh.

[01:35:23] And then, like, it's not just that you have to wear this and withstand it. You have to look good, act, get into the mindset of being a dwarf, and then, I don't know, tackle someone. I mean, I know they also have extras and things swapping in and out of these scenes, I'm sure, but, like, wow on all of them. The actors, the supporting, like, oh, that sounds terrible.

[01:35:53] It's very impressive. We also have another article about, this is from Nerdist, about the Rings of Power Season 3 soundtrack on vinyl and CD, and Nerdist got an exclusive preview of it, and this article is by Rotem Rusak, and he says, Dark times have come to Middle Earth in the Rings of Power Season 3, and that's reflected in every corner of this incredibly gorgeous soundtrack vinyl release.

[01:36:18] Salaron, the Nazganal, and even our good friend the Balrog have emerged from their respective fires to grace this darkly beautiful creation. And we have to hand it to Mutant. Even before we press play, we can feel the shadow reverberating through every inch of these gorgeous vinyl discs. The Rings of Power Season 3 soundtrack vinyl literally looks like we dipped the sound of Season 3 into Mount Doom and pulled it out encapsulated in molten lava. And we can't show you a picture on this podcast, of course,

[01:36:45] but I included a picture in the agenda for Veronica to see. It's very cool looking. So go to the link in the show notes, and they have photos in the article and also a link to where you can buy it. The article goes on, The Rings of Power Season 3 soundtrack doesn't just look good. Mutant shares that composer Bear McCreary created a whole new sound this season. They share that it was recorded at Air Studios and Abbey Road Studios in London, Synchron Stage in Vienna,

[01:37:14] and studios across Bulgaria, Finland, Iceland, Norway, and Los Angeles. The score features the mystery of the Bulgarian voices, the Trinity Boys Choir, and Finland's Shouting Men's Choir, Mezkjur... I have no idea how to pronounce this. Mezkjurohutajat. I know, right? I want to look this up. And lyrics are sung in Tolkien's Kenya, Quenya in the Black Speech, and Kuzdul.

[01:37:40] Jans Kidman returns alongside Vogelis Morgan's Sorn for Nazginal, a Black Speech setting of Tolkien's verse for the Nine. Katrine Stenbeck performs The Most Devoted in Quenya, while series stars Sofia Nonvedi, that's Diza, and Morphid Clark, Galadriel, lend their voices to Searching in Stone and Echoes of Ancient Music. The album closes with Where the Shadows Lie for Children's Choir, a new arrangement of the ring verse, first sung by Fiona Apple in Season 1.

[01:38:11] Yeah, it's really beautiful. I don't collect vinyl, but it's sort of tempting. I'm going to have to check it out. It's beautiful. I don't know where I would put it, and I don't have a turntable. It would be a whole thing. I know. So moving on to some listener feedback, we got a couple of voicemails, and here is the first one from Karen. This is about Episode 1. Hey, Rings of Power cast. This is Karen.

[01:38:39] I am reporting at this point just on Season 3, Episode 1. I want to say I, like Penny, was looking forward to the dwarf kids, and it appears that teenage dwarves are much like teenage humans. Yeah, I felt very... I was like, yeah, I'm with you, Diza. Yes, I get it. I thought it was interesting that Thrain, in my view,

[01:39:09] and I have a feeling you guys will come to this conclusion, is one of those guys who were like, oh, yeah, she was really into me. She totally liked me, and it's just like it's completely in his head. I mean, that's at least what Diza says, and I kind of want to believe Diza, that there was nothing there, and it was just all in his head. He's one of those guys. Finally, I think what I really want to talk about is Sauron,

[01:39:38] the sort of like coldness of him, the scene with the soldiers from Rune when, you know, first just stabbing the guys who dare to question in the back, and then having them fight. And he's sitting there, and if you notice when he's sitting there watching them, it's like it's a performance. He's tapping his feet, like tap, tap, tap, tap, and I'm like, oh, my God. He's like, this is fun.

[01:40:07] I'm like, that's as much emotion as he's going to show, but it's so like telling on who he is. And I also love the bit with his sort of mental image of Keller Brimboar, who's basically like mocking him, and, you know, like he, again, doesn't show the emotion, but you can tell that it's like he's so pissed off, but he's like not going to show it,

[01:40:32] and he just manifests it by having Keller Brimboar sit there and say, like, well, you're going to fail. You suck. And that's his, like, that's his manifesting of his own sort of doubt about this process and his anger. And I really loved it. I loved having him there. I'm like, yay, the actor gets to come back, even if it's just to like sit over Sauron's shoulder and like whisper things in his ear pretty much.

[01:41:01] So hopefully I'm going to watch. If I get to episode two tonight, then I'll just send both voicemails in together. All right. Bye. Thanks, Karen. So good to hear from you as always. And I guess we got sort of a middle ground with Disa and Thrain. Like she's not into him, but there is something that happened, but it was a one night stand. He's still one of those guys and he's just a jerk. Like he sucks.

[01:41:31] But he's still one of those guys. I didn't notice that Sauron was tapping his feet in that scene, but it makes sense that for him, it was like, it's like how I watch TV. He's like, yeah, fight to the death for fun. Gross. And in this episode, the way he killed those two elves, that was brutal. He had no intention of her ever being saved. Yeah. That was not fire drink.

[01:41:59] And I felt so bad for the husband being like, I'll do anything to save my wife. And yet still had to watch. And he didn't even kill that guy. He just walked away. Sauron was like, yeah, I killed your wife in front of you. And I'm not even going to watch her die. He turned his back and walked away. It was so dismissive and disrespectful and cold. And he got what he wanted, his background check on Marnok. Cold. Karen also sent in a voicemail about episode two.

[01:42:30] Hey, y'all. This is Karen for Rings of Power season three, episode two. I feel vindicated that Thrain is not only just a slimy person, but also in league with Sauron. So yes, bad. He was giving me bad vibes and I feel vindicated. Um, but sad for Durin because he's like, oh, you know, I'm suspicious. I don't think he's suspicious enough.

[01:42:59] Um, a question I'm hoping you guys cover is, uh, Sauron's like, oh yeah, Gandalf. I'm going to take care of him. And I'm like, how does he know Gandalf's name? Because the other guy just says this other wizard. And maybe it's because of way, way back in the past or it's been five years and he found out and he knows. I don't know. Like, I'm hoping that gets explained at some point.

[01:43:29] Um, and then the last thing is I thought, um, the actress playing Isildur's sister, I can't remember the name exactly. I'm going to get it wrong. So she's just going to be Isildur's sister. Um, she did such, such a good job of just like keeping her face and her posture and just being like, this is who I am playing her role perfectly, trying to turn that joking aside. Ha ha ha. Obviously it's not me.

[01:43:59] Like that's so silly. You know, unfortunately the game was already up. Um, and then just the power move of, I'm just going to walk off this balcony. And the fact that they just all stood there going, Oh, she's just going to get some air and, you know, and then we'll take her to the dungeon, you know? And it vaguely reminds me of, of Dumbledore saying, Oh, uh, did you think I was going to come quietly?

[01:44:27] Um, and that's pretty much what she does. She's just like, I'm not going to let them torture stuff out of me. I'm not going to tell them stuff. So this is my option. And without more than two seconds hesitation, she's like, okay, that's it. I'm going to do it. Um, I'm very sad that she's gone, but that was a, that was a boss move. Um, I'm really looking forward to seeing what happens next. Uh, yeah.

[01:44:57] So, and, uh, Farazan is, you know, slimy as hell as we know. Uh, and definitely paranoid and looking a little on edge. So we'll see how that goes. And I think that's about it for me. As I said, I don't think I'm going to catch up, but I'll only be a couple episodes behind, hopefully. All right. Bye. Bye, Karen. Thank you.

[01:45:25] We only have kind of half of the answer of how Sauron knows Gandalf's name. Bye. So hopefully we'll learn more in the future. But we did get that cool crow scene. So I'm happy about that. Uh, we also got a voicemail from our fearless leader, Miss Anwen, who could not be with us for this recording. So I'll play that now. And that's about these two episodes. Hey everyone. What a pair of episodes.

[01:45:55] The payoffs in these two episodes with Anarion, the blue wizards, Caliborn, the fell beasts, and the eagles was fantastic. Anarion was great. It was really cool to see him after being mentioned for two seasons. I can't believe that he and Elendil fell for the trap. Never trust someone in a cloak with their back to you. But it was worth it in the end to have them turn the tables and pin Kim into the carriage. Shout out to Leon Waddam for the fantastic acting. That face acting,

[01:46:24] right before he taunted Elendil about Anarion's death, you could see the pain and the torment flicker across his face. And then when Elendil was so gentle with him and offering him another path, he couldn't believe it. You know, he probably got more fatherly warmth in that one carriage ride than in a whole lifetime with Faraz on. It was really cool to see Bombadil again and learn more about the blue wizards and the secret fire. Mystery box unlocked. Celebrimbor,

[01:46:51] I love how it's obvious already how competent and powerful he is. And his quick turnaround as soon as he heard Galadriel's name was so funny. Their reunion was incredible, really moving. I can't wait to see more. And our poor Theo. We suspected he was on this path, but it was so much quicker than I imagined. And I love that he tried to give Arondir a chance, but so heartbreaking that he was all in about handing Galadriel over. Arondir, my sweet heartbroken elf.

[01:47:20] I did actually get spoiled on this character death, unfortunately, due to stupidly looking at Facebook before watching all four episodes. So I knew it was coming, but it was also kind of obvious from parts of the episode. They were really building up to it. All episode, every focus on him was getting us closer to his end. And once the ring servants showed up, I knew one was Theo and I could tell it would be him that was going to take Arondir down. It's just so tragic.

[01:47:49] But what a hero's ending. That proper slow-mo fall and the elf death music. We love and adore you, Arondir. May your stay in the halls of Mandos be brief, and your eternity in Valinor glorious. And we also love and adore you, the actor, Ishma Cruz Korova. Thank you for bringing us Arondir and just being unbelievably gorgeous and Alvin AF. That's all from me. See you next week. Nga maare. Nga maare, Yay, Anwin.

[01:48:19] Yeah, I watched these two episodes right away after we recorded last time, and I know that you guys, Veronica and Anwin, didn't get through them as fast. And I was sitting on the news of Arondir's death all by myself. Just like, I need to talk to somebody. I was so sad. It's brutal. But we're going to lose more people between now and the end. And like Anwin said,

[01:48:46] I'm glad he got like a sort of a featured heroic moment there. A beautiful death. It's tragic, but beautiful. Yeah. If you want to write in or leave us a message, you can find all our contact information at podcastticket.com. It's always in the show notes for every episode as well. Um,

[01:49:16] you can also see many of the other exciting shows that podcast has to offer at the website. Um, trying to think what I'm listening to right now, which is not a lot, but I am gearing up for yellow jackets. I cannot wait for the coverage on that. I can't wait for the conclusion of that show. The previews look amazing and it is so fun to listen to Penny.

[01:49:44] And Wendy and Daphne and Jason break down the episodes. Yeah. That's later this week. Freak out about it with me along the way. So I'm excited. You guys are going to, I'm excited for it. It's going to be really great. And I think that this final season is going to be outrageous and campy and dramatic and funny and all those things. And dark. So dark. I hope they land it.

[01:50:13] I hope people aren't frustrated with unresolved mysteries. Um, but I think. I think kind of regardless, it looks like it's at least going to be a fun. No Gladriel's mirror section this week because we don't have our resident here for Adriel with us. So next time we'll be covering season three episodes five and six. We don't have the titles of those yet. And that is our show.

[01:50:43] The only things in this world that are ever truly lost are those for which we cease to search.